« Speedwagon Rolls Out Category Feeds | Main | Link Building in the Google Supplemental Aftermath »
NY Times Select(s) Death over Charade
August 15, 2007
As you probably know, the NY Times has been the most prominent experiment in the paid content-behind-a-firewall-yet-at-least-partially-indexable model, and they are indeed now, finally, announcing via trial ballooning they are no longer going to put their most popular columnists behind that magic curtain one has to pay to sweep aside. After the magic show ends and the same fingers which initially drew the curtain are finished being pointed this way and that, this failed experiment will have had much to do with the principles of Link Building.
A party-goer cloaks her content as Maureen Dowd. Found on Flickr. Copyright 485i
First a great quote that helps explain the decision's relevance to our industry:
But the truth of the matter is that you get far more eyeballs when you're not locking away your content from the general public. The reality of Web 2.0 news is that people a rising tide raises all the ships. If you've got good content, and the Times does, people will link to it. When people read a technology blog like Engadget or a political blog like Daily Kos and find links to articles at the New York Times, everybody wins. Keeping your archives, op-eds, and other content locked up means that blogs and news sites won't link to you, won't give you credit for finding a story first, and won't drive up your traffic.
This lack of inbound links to the content-behind-the-firewall damaged traffic to the site not only through a paucity of visitors being able to click on these links to the columns themselves...:
...the share of traffic that the NY Times sends to NY Times Select has been decreasing over the past year – down by 16% year-on-year in July. With NY Times Select receiving more than two thirds (67%) of its US traffic from NYTimes.com, the decline had an impact with US visits to NY Select down 22% in the past year.
...in having to rely far too heavily on the parent site rather than third party links for traffic, but also in the residual effect such had in these columns' search engine visibility. With few third party inbound links accumulating with each new column, in fact from a deliberate online community decision not to link to content-behind-a-firewall, it is also very difficult for each new column to be judged more relevant than similarly themed columns emerging on the same topic that immediately acquire inbound links in the form of the same online community recommending them. It's no wonder the Times Select had to rely so heavily on clicks from the parent site for visits, as a great many of those visits were likely already subscribers. In that situation it is difficult to grow at the rate of the internet. Try these two simple searches for Frank and Maureen alone: nary a column to be found. Haven't they written quite a few?
I think everyone likely to read this blog knew this would happen. But to say we knew it would happen ultimately is not to say we are not happy to see even giants felled by an algorthm rejected, not select(ed).
All posts by John Lustina
posted by John Lustina at August 15, 2007 3:35 PM
Intrapromote: [ Case studies | SEO services | Bios ]
Trackback Pings
To TrackBack this entry, use the following URL:
http://seoblog.intrapromote.com/mt-tb.cgi/433
Comments
Hoeveel kan ik lenen? (hypotheek). Wat worden mijn maandlasten? (hypotheek) ... Hoeveel hypotheek heb ik nodig? Hoe hoog is de boete die ik nu zou moeten
Posted by: hypotheek at August 8, 2010 11:28 PM
I just adore stumbleupon for being able to show me this web page. instant fan now. I have viewed some definitely poor websites on stumble and when I discovered this, I immediately knew it was excellent! This blogpost is informative specifically for somebody like me haha. I've been attempting to read a lot more these days and being able to discover a web page like this can be excellent for my education. Love what you are doing, keep it up!
Posted by: Lock at August 14, 2010 1:09 AM
I like the format of the posts. Simple and straight to the point. I bet you'll be able to even do better. Write a lengthier write-up and show us what you are able to do. I have no doubt you might produce even much better content. I have subscribed to many blogs but this 1 is definitely a keeper!
Posted by: shower plumbing hardware at August 15, 2010 9:23 PM
I totally agree with you! We ought to all begin learning from this.
Posted by: sexy gril at August 25, 2010 9:12 PM
Sehr guter Beitrag.
Ich hoffe es lesen auch mal die richtigen.
Hab auch was dazu geschrieben: kühlschrank ohne gefrierfach
Vielleicht schaut mal einer vorbei.
Gruß
Posted by: Peter Kühlschrank at August 26, 2010 11:35 AM
I like the format of the posts. Simple and straight to the point. I bet you'll be able to even do better. Write a lengthier write-up and show us what you are able to do. I have no doubt you might produce even much better content. I have subscribed to many blogs but this 1 is definitely a keeper!
Posted by: send money to philippines at August 29, 2010 3:54 AM
I love stumbleupon for being able to show me this site. immediate fan now. I have viewed some really poor web sites on stumble and when I discovered this, I immediately knew it had been good! This article is entertaining especially for someone like me haha. I've been attempting to read a lot more these days and being able to discover a site like this is good for my education. Love what you are doing, looking forward to reading more!
Posted by: Honday Bay at August 29, 2010 11:27 AM
Posted by: Nileengib at August 30, 2010 12:36 AM